This Is What It Sounds Like…When Goats Cry

I wrote a post two years ago called “Letting Your Kids Cry It Out,” about crying goats in general. At that time, my only personal point of reference was Pasqualina’s crying as a wee kid when she was left alone–and by alone, I mean she was completely alone because we hadn’t yet found her a buddy.

But once we found her a friend, Margherita, she was fine. Crying stopped.

Well, here I am revisiting the crying goat issue because of a little crybaby named Gemma.

Gemma the baby goat


Mamma mia does this one cry!

(Video at the Goat Berries Facebook page.)

That video shows her more rational, lower-volumed crying as I approach, but when I’m at the house, a bit of a ways from where she stays, she WAILS several times a day for what seems like hours at a time. OK, it’s not really hours at a time; more like three minutes, but it *feels* like a lifetime when you’re in the midst of it.

When it first started happening, when she was about six weeks old, if it lasted for more than a few minutes and sounded urgent, I would go over to make sure she was OK. Always fresh water available and an all-you-can-eat-goatie-buffet, so it wasn’t like she needed anything in particular. Back then, I blamed teething. Right now I’m blaming weaning.

Truth be told, though, I think she just likes to have a human (ahem, me) around; whenever I show up *and* pay attention to her, she’s fine. If I just show up and don’t pay attention to her, as we say in Calabria, “GUAI!” Trouble, basically.

I’ve come to the conclusion that she has realized that wailing like she means it = maaaaa coming for petties and/or with treats.

So it has become necessary to just let the kid cry it out.

Hey, if it works for human babies, why not baby goats?

Now, to be clear, sometimes a goat’s crying can be a symptom of illness and/or discomfort, so you do want to rule out anything like that. But sooner or later the goat has to grow up, and that’s only going to happen if you let them figure out how to soothe themselves in times of stress or boredom or whatever it is that’s making them cry.

We’re in the first week of really, truly letting her cry it out. It’s been hard on maaaa, but it is definitely helping. I’ve also been making a point of going over and showing her love when she is *not* crying so she associates being calm with attention.

She is still crying out, but it’s only a couple times a day, pretty much when someone passes by or at feed-time, and she’ll give it maybe three good cries then stop.

That’s progress, right?

Just ask my neighbors!

Have you ever had a crybaby goat? What did you do?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
6 Responses to “This Is What It Sounds Like…When Goats Cry”
  1. 09.13.2012

    Right now I have a crier. Miss Penelope, who recently lost her Maa and is, well, not the strongest quite yet, is a sob-er. lol
    My heart breaks in pieces!
    Of course, if I sneak into the barn, she is fine……but let her hear my voice and all *guai!*
    breaks loose! ๐Ÿ™‚
    Miss Darla, when she returned from a 7 week stay at my townhouse, screamed herself hoarse for nearly three weeks…….

    What’s a goat mother to do…….? lol

    Gods, but we love them well, don’t we?



  2. 09.13.2012

    And Alpines are even worse! Oh, wait. That’s whining, not crying. Silly me. ๐Ÿ™‚


  3. 10.11.2012

    Caring for these wonderful critters must not give you a lot of free time unless you can get goat sitters. My wife and I were speaking to a woman at a local agricultural fair last week, and were amazed at how much milk they can produce and the attention they need.
    Loved the video.


    michelle Reply:

    Thx Greg; it does make going away as a couple rather difficult, esp since we also have dogs and hens and ducks and and and…… ๐Ÿ˜‰


  4. 12.19.2012

    I don’t have goats but I have seven dogs and one of the young ones, Patrick, howls like a hound dog and yet he is only a little Maltipoo/ShiTzu. Every time he hears me nearby this commences and it goes right through my head so I do the same as you –that is, I try to ignore it and creep slowly upstairs where he does not hear me!!!


    michelle Reply:

    Haha…yes, some animals just like to have company ๐Ÿ™‚


Leave a Reply


Goats that readers have spotted out and about. Send your photos to michelle(at)goatberries(dot)com! 

Baby the Goat in Georgia
Anguillian Goats
Goats in Central Park Zoo, NYC
Goats goats goats galore!
Tuscan goat
Goat on donkey (no not in that way)
Oman goat
Goat in tree in Africa
Testa Dura Goat Cheese
Goat at Maine Fiber Frolic 2011